Evaluation of Treatments in 2005

Evaluation of Treatments in 2005 in OH, IN, IL, and KY

Index of treatment success
T = 1 - [N_t/N_{t -1}]*[n_{t -1}/n_t]
Index of colony presence
C = N_t/n_t

Map of treatment blocks

Table with full information

(view with Excel, see legend)

Treatment EvaluationExplained

N_t and n_t are average moth counts in pheromone traps in year t in the treatment block and in the control area around it, respectively. Treatment is done in year t. In the case of mating disruption or intensive trapping, evaluation is performed in year t +1. Thus, N_t and n_t in equations for T and C are replaced by N_t+1 and n_t+1. If values of n_t-1 or n_t are less than 0.05, then they are replaced by the value of 0.05 for estimating of T. Treatment is successful if T > 0.67; partially successful if 0.33 < T < 0.67; and unsuccessful if T < 0.33. If C is much >1, then the colony is still present and may require additional treatments.

# Block Name State County Agent Dose Area,ac T T2 C PPA

1 Palos Park IL Cook Btk 24BIUx2 558 0.94 --- 35.70 10 2 Argonne IL Du Page MD 15g 2163 -0.07 0.76 14.56 43 3 Morton BTK IL Du Page Btk 24BIUx2 642 1.00 --- 0.03 31 4 Morton MD IL Du Page MD 15g 5130 --- --- --- 31 5 Winfield/DCFP IL Du Page MD 15g 1548 0.98 0.97 0.64 29 6 Rockford 1 IL Winnebago Btk 24BIUx2 336 0.17 --- 4.71 18 7 Rockford 2 IL Winnebago MD 6g 2393 0.25 -2.84 2.69 18 8 Arcola IN Allen Btk 30BIUx2 20 -0.74 --- 36.67 35 9 Cedarville IN Allen Btk 30BIUx2 870 0.99 --- 0.58 50 10 Fort Wayne East IN Allen Btk 30BIUx2 2889 0.72 --- 3.90 46 11 leesburg road IN Allen Btk 30BIUx2 27 0.56 --- 7.23 35 12 Sheriff's Dept IN Allen Btk 30BIUx2 96 0.95 --- 1.75 43 13 Pierceton 05 IN Kosciusko Btk 30BIUx2 147 0.98 --- 0.41 101 14 SR 15 & 900 North IN Kosciusko Btk 30BIUx2 13 0.95 --- 3.92 23 15 300 E-01 IN La Porte MD 15g 3294 0.98 0.98 0.15 9 16 300 E-02 IN La Porte MD 15g 31 1.00 0.97 0.00 9 17 50 W-01 IN La Porte MD 6g 168 0.94 0.91 1.16 97 18 50 W-02 IN La Porte MD 6g 138 0.96 0.91 0.92 97 19 Bendix County Park IN La Porte MD 15g 982 1.00 0.99 0.05 10 20 Lake Shore & Ridgemoore IN La Porte MD 6g 213 -1.10 -0.05 0.92 -1 21 Northbrook 05-01 IN La Porte MD 6g 703 -0.70 -0.31 1.77 103 22 Northbrook 05-02 IN La Porte MD 6g 257 -4.04 -2.35 1.67 103 23 Prison IN La Porte MD 6g 185 0.99 0.96 0.61 5 24 Bremen South IN Marshall Btk 30BIUx2 18 0.47 --- 16.35 15 25 300 South 05 IN Noble Btk 30BIUx2 228 0.77 --- 3.09 33 26 Ligonier IN Noble Btk 30BIUx2 3 0.99 --- 0.43 30 27 Merriam 05 IN Noble Btk 30BIUx2 364 0.85 --- 1.09 33 28 Cobb's Corner 05 IN Porter Btk 30BIUx2 69 0.54 --- 38.30 3 29 Bremen North IN St. Joseph Btk 30BIUx2 4 0.99 --- 0.18 15 30 Brick Rd & Auten IN St. Joseph Btk 30BIUx2 406 0.89 --- 0.23 12 31 Ironwood IN St. Joseph MD 6g 2681 0.20 0.09 0.09 99 32 300 South & 650 East IN Whitley Btk 30BIUx2 5 0.94 --- 30.18 94 33 Lincoln Way IN Whitley Btk 30BIUx2 68 0.96 --- 2.35 32 34 South Charleston OH Clark Btk 24BIUx2 12 0.82 --- 26.21 25 35 Springfield OH Clark Dim 1oz 789 0.99 --- 2.40 22 36 Defiance East 1 OH Defiance Btk 24BIUx2 465 --- --- --- 8 37 Defiance East 2 OH Defiance Btk 24BIUx2 992 0.79 --- 3.96 8 38 Ostrander OH Delaware MD 6g 4220 0.96 -1.04 0.39 61 39 Powell 1 East OH Delaware MD 6g 844 0.60 1.07 1.06 69 40 Powell 1 West OH Delaware MD 6g 453 0.82 1.07 0.49 69 41 Powell 2 OH Delaware Btk 24BIUx2 21 0.90 --- 0.35 69 42 Powell 3 OH Delaware Dim 1oz 1 0.82 --- 0.46 69 43 New Holland OH Fayette MD 6g 34 1.00 0.77 0.00 50 44 New Martinsburg OH Fayette Btk 24BIUx2 36 --- --- --- 44 45 Jeffery Park OH Franklin Btk 38BIUx1 45 -276.68 --- 2.64 -1 46 OSU 1 OH Franklin Btk 38BIUx1 6 0.89 --- 2.12 75 47 OSU 2 OH Franklin Btk 38BIUx1 7 0.90 --- 1.89 75 48 OSU 3 OH Franklin Btk 38BIUx1 20 0.91 --- 12.02 75 49 Schiller Park OH Franklin Btk 38BIUx1 25 --- --- 3.52 -1 50 Southwest Columbus OH Franklin Btk 38BIUx1 254 0.77 --- 1.31 68 51 Greenfield OH Highland MD 6g 237 0.94 0.76 0.98 40 52 Beaver 1 OH Jackson Btk 24BIUx2 2390 0.67 --- 1.46 81 53 Beaver 2 OH Jackson NPV 5x10^111 507 0.87 --- 1.13 81 54 Zanesfield OH Logan Btk 24BIUx2 300 0.99 --- 0.40 27 55 Plain City OH Madison Btk 24BIUx2 64 0.70 --- 2.00 47 56 New Haven OH Meigs MD 6g 1119 0.81 0.16 0.23 102 57 Grover Hill 1 OH Paulding Btk 24BIUx2 45 0.86 --- 2.29 5 58 Grover Hill 2 OH Paulding Btk 24BIUx2 81 0.94 --- 0.89 5 59 Grover Hill 3 OH Paulding Btk 24BIUx2 192 0.80 --- 1.72 5 60 Oakwood 2005 OH Paulding Btk 24BIUx2 151 0.91 --- 0.93 7 61 Williamsport OH Pickaway Btk 24BIUx2 233 0.70 --- 1.80 71 62 Auerville OH Pike Btk 24BIUx2 1953 -0.52 --- 4.14 43 63 Lapperal OH Pike Btk 24BIUx2 5130 0.98 --- 0.29 43 64 Pine Top OH Pike Btk 24BIUx2 973 0.79 --- 0.12 43 65 Stockdale OH Pike Btk 24BIUx2 1337 0.93 --- 0.47 85 66 Tiffin North OH Seneca Btk 24BIUx2 40 --- --- 3.68 -1 67 Tiffin South OH Seneca Btk 24BIUx2 595 0.70 --- 0.63 -1 68 Shawnee Hills OH Union Btk 24BIUx2 114 0.97 --- 0.16 58

Blocks outside of STS action zone

 #  Block Name                    State County         Agent  Dose    Area,ac    T      T2       C    PPA

69  BarringtonHills               IL    Cook           MD     15g      2654    -1.01    0.36    1.40   26
70  Countryside/CFPD 1            IL    Cook           Btk    24BIUx2   378     1.00     ---    0.01   35
71  Countryside/CFPD 2            IL    Cook           MD     15g      1366     0.99    0.99    0.95   35
72  Elgin                         IL    Cook           Btk    24BIUx2    38     0.87     ---    5.92   27
73  Addison                       IL    Du Page        Btk    24BIUx1   611     0.93     ---    1.47   30
74  Glen Ellyn/Churchill 1        IL    Du Page        Btk    24BIUx2  1047     1.00     ---    0.00   30
75  GlenEllyn/Churchill 2         IL    Du Page        MD     6g       3871     1.00    0.99    0.12   30
76  Carpentersville               IL    Kane           MD     15g      8833     0.86    0.70    0.10   26
77  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 21IN    Allen          MD     15g       546     0.99    0.98    0.07   48
78  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 22IN    Allen          MD     15g        40     0.50    0.98    1.15   48
79  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 23IN    Allen          MD     15g        29     0.79    0.97    0.36   48
80  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 24IN    Allen          MD     15g       399      ---     ---     ---   48
81  Dekalb Co Airport - 01        IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       123     0.95    0.65    0.03   47
82  Dekalb Co Airport - 02        IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        37      ---     ---     ---   47
83  Dekalb Co Airport - 03        IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       386     0.96    0.93    0.10   47
84  Dekalb Co Airport - 04        IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       292     0.97    0.93    0.10   47
85  Dekalb Co Airport - 05        IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       211     0.94    0.90    0.14   47
86  Dekalb Co Airport - 08        IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        85     0.95    1.05    0.13   47
87  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 01IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        42     0.96    0.91    0.17   48
88  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 02IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       131     0.86    0.62    0.20   48
89  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 03IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        37     0.62    0.21    0.31   48
90  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 04IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       294     0.83    0.37    0.15   48
91  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 05IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        79     0.46    0.12    0.32   48
92  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 06IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       162     0.96    0.96    0.30   48
93  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 07IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        67     0.81    0.94    0.69   48
94  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 08IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       234     0.83    0.91    0.62   48
95  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 09IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        72    -0.02    0.67    0.77   48
96  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 10IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       114     1.00    0.99    0.07   48
97  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 11IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        78     0.98    0.96    0.08   48
98  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 12IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        57     0.96    0.90    0.13   48
99  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 13IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        54     0.23    0.81    0.41   48
100  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 14IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        40     0.84    0.75    0.17   48
101  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 15IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        86     0.93    0.15    0.03   48
102  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 16IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       248     0.91    0.91    0.20   48
103  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 17IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       622     0.93    0.95    0.22   48
104  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 18IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        89     0.84    0.88    0.09   48
105  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 19IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       223     0.62    0.94    0.46   48
106  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 20IN    De Kalb        MD     15g        32     0.86    0.97    0.75   48
107  Saint Joe  & Spencerville - 25IN    De Kalb        MD     15g       371     0.70    0.82    0.51   48
108  Bristol                       IN    Elkhart        Btk    30BIUx1   132     0.93     ---    0.67   25
109  Elcona C.C.                   IN    Elkhart        Btk    30BIUx1   792     0.98     ---    0.04   24
110  Middlebury cr37               IN    Elkhart        Btk    30BIUx2     7     0.95     ---    6.15   27
111  Millersburg                   IN    Elkhart        Btk    30BIUx2     9     0.87     ---    6.25   28
112  Topeka                        IN    Lagrange       Btk    30BIUx2   486     0.94     ---    1.09   95

PPA = Potential Problem Area, detected by the Decision Algorithm from previous year data.
Treatment agents: Btk (or Bt, BT) = Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki;
MD (or PF) = Mating disruption with pheromone flakes containing disparlure;
NPV = virus, preparation Gypchek;
DIM = Dimilin (=diflubenzuron);
Trap = Mass trapping;

Back to the STS Decision-Support system

For more information, please contact Patrick Tobin or Andy Roberts
Maintained By Jiang Wu