Evaluation of Treatments in 2010

Evaluation of Treatments in 2010 in OH, IN, IL, and KY

Index of treatment success
T = 1 - [N_t/N_{t -1}]*[n_{t -1}/n_t]
Index of colony presence
C = N_t/n_t

Map of treatment blocks

Table with full information

(view with Excel, see legend)

Treatment EvaluationExplained

N_t and n_t are average moth counts in pheromone traps in year t in the treatment block and in the control area around it, respectively. Treatment is done in year t. In the case of mating disruption or intensive trapping, evaluation is performed in year t +1. Thus, N_t and n_t in equations for T and C are replaced by N_t+1 and n_t+1. If values of n_t-1 or n_t are less than 0.05, then they are replaced by the value of 0.05 for estimating of T. Treatment is successful if T > 0.67; partially successful if 0.33 < T < 0.67; and unsuccessful if T < 0.33. If C is much >1, then the colony is still present and may require additional treatments.

# Block Name State County Agent Dose Area,ac T T2 C PPA

1 Amboy BTK IL Lee Btk 24BIUx2 99 0.79 --- 9.23 10 2 Coal City BTK IL Grundy Btk 24BIUx2 203 1.00 --- 0.00 36 3 Franklin Grove MD IL Lee MD 6g 541 0.99 1.00 0.28 13 4 Lena (MD) 7 IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 430 0.74 --- 0.90 7 5 Lena BTK 1 IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 103 --- --- --- 7 6 Lena BTK 2 IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 2 --- --- --- 7 7 Lena BTK 3 IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 11 0.72 --- 10.05 7 8 Lena BTK 4 IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 17 0.80 --- 15.56 7 9 Lena BTK 5 IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 80 -0.24 --- 5.31 7 10 Lena BTK 6 IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 48 0.21 --- 4.99 7 11 Loran BTK IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 8 0.93 --- 2.15 6 12 Menominee MD IL Jo Daviess MD 6g 1223 0.97 1.00 0.62 1 13 Newark BTK 1 IL Kendall Btk 24BIUx2 64 0.82 --- 1.54 57 14 Newark BTK 2 IL Kendall Btk 24BIUx2 34 0.94 --- 0.75 57 15 Newark BTK 3 IL Kendall Btk 24BIUx2 16 0.82 --- 1.78 57 16 Newark BTK 4 IL Kendall Btk 24BIUx2 45 0.83 --- 2.11 57 17 Newark BTK 5 IL Kendall Btk 24BIUx2 8 0.83 --- 2.12 57 18 Park Forest MD IL Will MD 6g 1049 1.00 1.00 0.00 47 19 Plano IL Kendall Btk 24BIUx2 158 --- --- --- 58 20 Rock City IL Stephenson Btk 24BIUx2 8 -0.34 --- 17.08 74 21 Sheridan BTK IL La Salle Btk 24BIUx2 110 0.98 --- 0.43 29 22 Stillman Valley BTK 1 IL Ogle Btk 24BIUx2 59 --- --- --- 78 23 Stillman Valley BTK 2 IL Ogle Btk 24BIUx2 59 --- --- --- 78 24 Wilmington MD IL Will MD 6g 591 0.30 1.00 1.52 63 25 Aboite-1 IN Allen Btk 25BIUx2 988 0.79 --- 0.78 52 26 Aboite-2 IN Allen Btk 25BIUx2 1084 0.35 --- 0.87 54 27 Aboite-3 IN Allen Btk 25BIUx2 808 0.64 --- 1.23 54 28 Aboite-4 IN Allen Btk 25BIUx2 1505 0.48 --- 2.02 54 29 Lagro-1 IN Huntington MD 6g 2178 1.00 -0.79 0.00 37 30 Lagro-2 IN Huntington MD 6g 4414 1.00 0.61 0.00 37 31 Lagro-3 IN Wabash MD 6g 3370 0.99 0.96 0.04 37 32 Lagro-4 IN Wabash MD 6g 1852 0.99 1.00 0.06 37 33 Lagro-5 IN Wabash MD 6g 1228 1.00 1.00 0.00 37 34 Leesburg-1 IN Kosciusko Btk 25BIUx2 224 0.74 --- 0.46 35 35 Leesburg-2 IN Kosciusko Btk 25BIUx2 316 0.84 --- 0.34 35 36 Leesburg-3 IN Kosciusko Btk 25BIUx2 19 0.54 --- 0.57 35 37 Leesburg-4 IN Kosciusko Btk 25BIUx2 26 0.76 --- 0.64 35 38 Leesburg-5 IN Kosciusko Btk 25BIUx2 53 0.87 --- 1.59 35 39 Leesburg-6 IN Kosciusko Btk 25BIUx2 16 0.81 --- 0.58 35 40 Leesburg-7 IN Kosciusko Btk 25BIUx2 36 0.78 --- 1.01 35 41 Tippecanoe IN Marshall MD 6g 565 0.96 1.00 0.46 29 42 Alger BTK OH Hardin Btk 24BIUx2 29 0.99 --- 0.03 46 43 Bellefontaine MD OH Logan MD 6g 11593 0.96 0.74 0.09 55 44 Big Plain A BTK OH Madison Btk 24BIUx2 25 0.70 --- 2.05 500 45 Big Plain B BTK OH Madison Btk 24BIUx2 19 0.57 --- 1.01 500 46 Clifton A BTK OH Clark Btk 24BIUx2 161 -5.27 --- 13.90 50 47 Clifton B BTK OH Clark Btk 24BIUx2 105 -13.20 --- 25.89 50 48 Clifton C BTK OH Clark Btk 24BIUx2 33 0.89 --- 0.18 -1 49 East Liberty A NPV OH Union NPV-MD 5x10^11 268 0.96 0.99 0.52 69 50 East Liberty B NPV OH Logan NPV-MD 5x10^11 138 0.94 0.09 1.90 69 51 East Liberty C NPV OH Union NPV-MD 5x10^11 374 0.99 0.93 0.15 69 52 East Liberty D NPV OH Union NPV-MD 5x10^11 146 1.00 0.97 0.00 69 53 East Liberty MD OH Union MD 6g 28001 0.94 0.82 0.22 69 54 Five Points A BTK OH Pickaway Btk 24BIUx2 48 -5.19 --- 180.29 83 55 Five Points B BTK OH Pickaway Btk 24BIUx2 4 -4.16 --- 119.05 83 56 Gallia MD OH Gallia MD 15g 230 1.00 1.00 0.00 101 57 Grover Hill A MD OH Paulding MD 6g 983 0.96 0.47 0.04 8 58 Grover Hill B MD OH Paulding MD 6g 640 1.00 0.86 0.00 -1 59 Kalida A BTK OH Putnam Btk 24BIUx2 23 0.99 --- 0.16 23 60 Kalida B BTK OH Putnam Btk 24BIUx2 38 1.00 --- 0.00 23 61 Kettering BTK OH Montgomery Btk 24BIUx2 1271 0.97 --- 3.06 22 62 Lima A BTK OH Allen Btk 24BIUx2 319 0.98 --- 0.20 25 63 Lima B BTK OH Allen Btk 24BIUx2 163 0.81 --- 0.85 25 64 Mineral MD A OH Vinton MD 6g 16724 0.87 0.86 0.37 104 65 Mineral MD B OH Vinton MD 15g 32885 0.99 0.93 0.02 104 66 Oak Hill A MD OH Jackson MD 6g 673 1.00 0.96 0.00 100 67 Oak Hill B MD OH Jackson MD 6g 431 0.96 1.00 0.12 102 68 Oakwood A MD OH Paulding MD 6g 1624 1.00 0.62 0.00 7 69 Oakwood B MD OH Paulding MD 6g 533 0.54 0.69 1.69 9 70 Oakwood C MD OH Paulding MD 6g 232 1.00 0.57 0.00 9 71 Rainsboro BTK OH Highland Btk 24BIUx2 412 0.99 --- 1.30 79 72 Roundhead MD OH Logan MD 6g 913 0.21 0.83 0.56 51 73 Rushsylvania A MD OH Logan MD 6g 4015 0.86 0.73 0.17 65 74 Rushsylvania B BTK OH Logan Btk-MD 24BIUx1 59 0.02 0.80 2.57 61 75 Rushsylvania B MD OH Logan MD 6g 2603 0.39 0.81 0.67 61 76 Yellow Springs E MD OH Greene MD 6g 1793 0.97 1.00 0.16 39 77 Yellow Springs W BTK OH Greene Btk-MD 24BIUx1 72 0.74 1.00 5.64 39 78 Yellow Springs W MD OH Greene MD 6g 1427 0.84 0.98 0.88 39

Blocks outside of STS action zone

 #  Block Name                    State County         Agent  Dose    Area,ac    T      T2       C    PPA

79  Park Forest BTK               IL    Cook           Btk    24BIUx2  1886     0.98     ---    0.09   48
80  Park Forest MD2               IL    Will           MD     6g        115     1.00    5.66    0.00   48
81  Rockford BTK                  IL    Winnebago      Btk    24BIUx2    49     0.83     ---    1.99   80
82  Romeoville BTK                IL    Will           Btk    24BIUx2   286     0.78     ---    0.72   66
83  Hobart-MD1                    IN    Lake           MD     6g       1083     0.83    1.00    0.40   4
84  Hobart-MD2                    IN    Lake           MD     6g        935     0.89    1.00    0.21   4
85  Hobart-MD3                    IN    Porter         MD     6g        743     0.89    0.26    0.23   4
86  Hobart-MD4                    IN    Lake           MD     6g        889     0.85    0.90    0.39   4
87  Circleville BTK               OH    Pickaway       Btk-MD 24BIUx1   694     0.70    1.00    9.91   91
88  Circleville MD                OH    Pickaway       MD     6g      17358     0.75    0.99    1.56   91
89  Galloway MD                   OH    Franklin       MD     15g      6485     0.99    1.00    0.02   82
90  Harrisburg BTK                OH    Franklin       Btk    24BIUx2   321      ---     ---     ---   84
91  Monroe BTK                    OH    Butler         Btk    24BIUx2   262     1.00     ---    0.00   10
92  South Bloomingville BTK       OH    Hocking        Btk-MD 24BIUx1  1375     0.84    0.29    0.14   99
93  South Bloomingville MD        OH    Hocking        MD     6g      14855     0.89   -3.40    0.05   99
94  West Mansfield BTK            OH    Union          Btk    24BIUx2   120    -3.06     ---    5.78   71

PPA = Potential Problem Area, detected by the Decision Algorithm from previous year data.
Treatment agents: Btk (or Bt, BT) = Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki;
MD (or PF) = Mating disruption with pheromone flakes containing disparlure;
NPV = virus, preparation Gypchek;
DIM = Dimilin (=diflubenzuron);
Trap = Mass trapping;

Back to the STS Decision-Support system

For more information, please contact Patrick Tobin or Andy Roberts
Maintained By Jiang Wu